Cookie Flavors

Casey’s Cookies offers 6 signature flavors and 2 Sugar-Free options for our gourmet cookies. Our most popular cookie has proved to be the Quadruple Chocolate Chip which is made with Ghirardelli double chocolate, Hershey's milk chocolate, semi-sweet chocolate, and white chocolate chips – a chocolate masterpiece! The White Chocolate Vermont Maple Cookies are a savory flavor due to the rich taste the maple gives. Our Cake Batter Sugar Cookies are made with cake mix and rolled in colorful sprinkles, making them a favorite with all ages. The Blueberry White Chip with Lemon Zest Cookies and the Cranberry White Chip with Orange Zest Cookies have been met with rave reviews for their distinct way of making the most of the berry flavorings. Our Cinnamon Chip Oatmeal Raisin Cookies are a new twist on a traditional recipe, with the cinnamon chips and golden raisins bringing a whole new level of taste. We also have Sugar-Free Chocolate and Sugar-Free Vanilla Cookies made from Splenda cake mixes, which bring to mind the flavor of “brownies” or “blondies” and are always a welcome treat for those who must avoid sugar. If you can’t decide on just one, order the Assorted Cookies option that includes our 6 signature flavors for the chance to have a cookie experience you’ll never forget and hopefully leave your taste buds wanting more!